Education News

Six reasons we must address our nation’s crumbling school buildings

By Amanda Menas / Photo: NEA President Lily Eskelsen Garcia at the Rayburn Building

Too many students and educators across the country learn and work in crumbling schools.

In California, one teacher reported that students are instructed to run the water for one minute before drinking to prevent lead contamination. In one Idaho school, educators see mice come in each winter and water seeps in when it rains. Similar problems exist in every state and every congressional district.  

America’s public schools are one of the largest sectors of our nation’s infrastructure, second only to roads and highways. We need to invest in school modernization as a crucial part of any major infrastructure push. Speaker Nancy Pelosi (D-CA) has pointedly said that schools will be addressed by House Democrats this year. What form that takes is still unknown.

“For far too long, we have chronically underfunded our schools. And as a result, many educators and students are stuck with facing unwelcoming to even hazardous learning environments. On a daily basis, these public schools face numerous infrastructure challenges, ranging from moldy ceiling tiles to inoperable heating and cooling systems. And that is in the most minor circumstances,” said NEA President Lily Eskelsen at a House Education and Labor Committee press conference on March 3, 2020.

Educators are embracing a plan by House and Senate Democrats to invest more than $100 billion in America’s public schools. The Rebuild America’s Schools Act would fund $70 billion in grants and $30 billion in bonds to help states address critical physical and digital infrastructure needs. The act is an important step in securing safe, high-quality public schools for every student. 

Here are six reasons schools should be included in the upcoming infrastructure legislation:

1. Half of America’s public schools are more than 50 years old

The American Society of Civil Engineers gives the condition of America’s 100,000 public school buildings an overall grade of D+ rating. This means that twenty-four percent of schools in permanent buildings and 31 percent of schools in temporary buildings are in “fair” or “poor” condition. NEA has advocated for the development of a comprehensive national database on the condition of public school facilities. Such a national database currently does not exist and would provide much-needed insight into the condition of our public schools. 

2. Students in some rural areas are without internet connection

Campuses in poorer rural and urban areas tend to have the worst facilities because they lack local revenue to pay for school upkeep and modernization projects. Over 19,000 schools serving 11.6 million students do not have the minimum connectivity necessary for digital learning. To ensure that public schools have the reliable and high-speed Internet access they need for digital learning, there must be expanded access to high-speed broadband.  One way to solve these major education disparities would be to leverage existing public programs or public-private partnerships to expand access to high-speed broadband sufficient for digital learning.  

3. Our most vulnerable students are hurt the most

A 2006 Building Education Success Together report found that high-poverty and minority-serving schools are unable to adequately invest in school facilities. These school facilities have time and time again failed to serve students by providing poor breathing conditions. According to a 2014 CDC survey, only 46.5% of schools have a program in place today to address indoor air quality issues, and the GAO found that over 15,000 schools were circulating air unfit to breathe. Additionally, schools predominantly serving white students spend nearly 50% more on capital construction than those serving minority students, and wealthy districts spend nearly triple their high-poverty counterparts. A 1996 GAO Report—the most recent GAO study on this issue—determined that poor school facility conditions were concentrated in high-poverty schools serving minority students.

4. Poor conditions force teachers out of the profession

Not only do students suffer when learning in underfunded school facilities, so do educators. Based on an Economic Policy Institute analysis, every $1 billion spent on construction creates 17,785 jobs. The U.S. Department of Education estimates that it would cost about $4.5 million per school — a total of $197 billion — to make the repairs and renovations necessary to ensure that all our public schools are in good condition. By leveraging federal, state, and local resources, over 1.9 million jobs could be created in the education sector alone. Investing in school infrastructure is investing in education and the economy.

5. Parents can’t raise enough money

While some school districts allow parent groups to raise money to supplement local and federal funding, others cannot afford to or are strictly prohibited. Students and educators need support through innovative solutions, especially with increased disparities between wealthier schools and classrooms in poorer areas. One NEA-endorsed suggestion is to restore the Quality Zone Academy Bonds (QZABs), which the Republican Tax Deal eliminated, and permanently increases the national limit from $400 million to $1.4 billion per year. QZABs allow qualifying schools to finance renovations, repairs, and investments in technology at below-market rates — sometimes, as low as zero. School districts pay back the amount of money borrowed initially, but do not have to pay any interest — typically, about half the cost of renovating a school.

6. Children are exposed to toxic elements

The U.S. Environmental Protection Agency attributes poor indoor air quality in more than 60,000 schools to insects, rodents, dust mites, fungi, and respiratory irritants from sources of formaldehyde and nitrogen dioxide. Educators across the country support creating a $70 billion grant program and $30 billion tax credit bond program targeted at high-poverty schools with facilities that pose health and safety risks to students and staff.  

10 responses to “Six reasons we must address our nation’s crumbling school buildings

  1. For two years my classroom had no heat. Because it also had no air conditioning, I had to buy box fans for summer when the thermostat showed 98 degrees. Meanwhile, our vent was open to the boy’s bathroom. That’s at a medium-well funded district.

    1. As go the children so goes the community (country). Our children are tomorrows, American leaders. If we continue to shortchange them, we will pay for it handsomely. We solve any of our biggest problems without properly educating our children.

    2. Our future does depend on our children but this statement and it’s tenets are deeper than the school day. Schools have become so focused on Academic standards and growth that they have overlooked the goal to build good citizens. Young adults who have talents outside of reading and writing. Young adults who not only show empathy to others but are willing to make changes to improve the lives of others. Young adults who are physically fit not to become professional athletes but to be healthy. Young adults who are exposed to a plethora of arts and technical skills that can simply enhance their character and the viability of the community in which they live. This is was the goals of the school and this is why I became a teacher to share my talent for not only reading books but a dress pattern, for synchronized swimming, for knitting, for lively discussion and so many more skills that I hoped to obtain- not simply to learn a skill to pass a TEST.

  2. Wealthy CEO’s and workers in the higher tax brackets can’t be concerned with paying for other people’s stuff, they already got enough to pay for. Until they can or are forced to this situation will continue to go unaddressed. We live in a 1st World Nation, yet many of our schools are looking like they were built in a 3rd world nation.

  3. Books are also crumbling. Last year when I taught physical science, I taught 5 classes of max 30 students in each class. There was only one set of books for all 5 classes to use and they have to use them in class. They are stacked up for the next class each school day. Pages are missing from many of the books as students stole pages to take home to study.

    But these books would be carriers of novel coronavirus, flu viruses, etc. Gone are the days when each student had their own books to use. So books must be part of the infrastructure.

  4. Public education is the key to sustaining and growing all if America
    How utterly foolish and ignorant to not support this

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *