5 Things to Know About the Dream and Promise Act of 2019

This week, the U.S. House of Representatives introduced an updated Dream Act that gives hope and dignity to aspiring new Americans while aiming to provide a pathway to citizenship for the millions of individuals known as “Dreamers” who came to the United States as minors.

The introduction of the Dream and Promise Act of 2019 (H.R. 6) reflects the tireless work of legislators, students, activists, and organizations on behalf of immigrants. Together, these advocates are exhibiting their respect and concern for Dreamers and other beneficiaries of Temporary Protected Status (TPS) and Deferred Enforced Departure (DED) from ongoing attacks by the Trump administration.

“The American people elected a new Democratic majority that would uphold our values of liberty, justice and opportunity,” said Speaker of the House Nancy Pelosi (D-CA).

1. What Will the Bill Accomplish?

President Trump recklessly terminated the Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) program in 2017 which left thousands of students, teachers, members of the military and working families in limbo and under the threat of deportation. He also revoked TPS, which protects immigrants from  countries deemed  unsafe due to armed conflict, natural disaster, epidemic or other extraordinary conditions.  Both programs  provided work permits and stability families who have strong roots in the U.S. The new proposal offers young immigrants and TPS holders a path to citizenship  while upholding U.S. values of welcoming immigrants and their many social, economic, and cultural contributions to the nation.

2. Why Pass the Bill Now?

The bill would help approximately 3.6 million Dreamers, including the 800,000 who have been shielded from deportation and granted a work permit under DACA. The legislation provides protection and certainty to our neighbors, friends, many who are students and educators in our schools. The bill not only helps families stay together and secure long-term economic stability, but also enables thousands of students to pursue their education and career goals by opening financial aid and college loans.

3. How Does the Bill Affect Students and Educators?

Under current law, without H.R. 6 in place, some educators and students will lose their protected status. Consequently, educators will lose their work permits. These losses will cause the removal of hundreds of thousands of teachers, education support professionals (ESP) and others from schools and classrooms. In addition, educators will lose their ability to support their families, pay their mortgages, and maintain their employer-provided health insurance. Ultimately, they will be at risk for deportation.

By the numbers:

  • The Migration Policy Institute estimates that there are about a quarter-million students who are DACA-eligible since the program went into effect in 2012.
  • According to public data, there are approximately 9,000 educators working in our nation’s public schools who are DACA recipients.
  • Millions of students enrolled in public schools are children of unauthorized immigrants according to the Pew Research Center.
    • In California alone, more than 50,000 children were born in the U.S. but have Salvadoran parents who face deportation due to losing their TPS.
  • According to the Center for Migration Studies, about 1,400 Salvadoran teachers in the United States have humanitarian Temporary Protection Status.
  • The American Immigration Council notes that there are about 1,000 Haitians working as educators in K-12 schools in the United States.

4. How is the 2019 Dreamer bill different from the last version?

California Rep. Lucille Roybal-Allard, who co-authored the original Dream Act in 2001, said the updated legislation will give Dreamers access to in-state tuition and federal student financial aid. It will also permit eligible Dreamers who were deported by the Trump administration to apply for relief. “Our bill contains a number of provisions that make it more progressive and pragmatic than previous versions of the Dream Act,” said Roybal-Allard, a co-sponsor of the new bill. “I have seen the pain and fear the Trump administration has had on Dreamers and their families.”

5. How can I Make my Voice Heard?

NEA calls on Congress to quickly pass the Dream and Promise Act of 2019 and is committed to continuing to work with friends and allies to stand up to the Trump administration’s attacks on the safety and wellbeing of immigrant families.

Click here to urge your Congressional representative to support H.R. 6.

“Trump’s treatment of them is inhumane, cruel, and contrary to the values that we hold dear as a nation,” says NEA President Lily Eskelsen García.

109 responses to “5 Things to Know About the Dream and Promise Act of 2019

  1. To the Haters on this feed, YOU don’t represent the values of America.

    America was built on stolen land and unless you are Native American; your family immigrated here at some point. If you were born here, you were just lucky. You didn’t earn being here; therefore you have not earned any right to act superior to other people, who have grown up here and have been vetted and got their DACA papers. They should be Naturalization papers.

    2014 Naturalization Facts:
    The United States has a long history of welcoming immigrants from all parts of the world. During the last decade, U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS) welcomed more than 6.6 million naturalized citizens into the fabric of our nation.

    The fact that undocumented workers from south of the border haven’t been able to be Naturalized is because they are discriminated against and Congress has refused to create a pathway to citizenship, even tho’ Obama promised one.

    Understand, Naturalization requires vetting and therefore not everyone would qualify. But undocumented workers can’t even apply.

    DACA people have already been vetted; they are not criminals and they are going to school and/or working and deserve to be here.

  2. It just baffles me to see what people think about Dreamers and “illegal” immigrants.

    These “illegals” you speak of do not take money from your “pot” of gold. These immigrants are only allowed to add to the pot, but never even have the opportunity to receive its fruition.

    These Dreamers, if lucky, were able to attend school as an “international student” paying double the instate tuirion of their fellow peers. Through DACA, they were able to finally receive some sort of resolution in SOME states.

    Dreamers and “illegal” immigrants should be the last of your worries. These people work hard contributing millions of dollars into the economy as well as into the government.

    So please, look in the mirror and see if your contributions are even remotely close.

    Thank you for coming to my TED talk.

  3. I am in support of H.R. 6 because this is the place that most of these immigrants know as home. We cannot turn out backs on them now when they want a better life.

    1. The law is the law. If these illegals can simply waltz into MY COUNTRY and get the benefits of an AMERICAN CITIZEN, then I shouldn’t have to obey speed limit signs while I’m driving. Breaking the law is breaking the law NO MATTER HOW you want to do it!!! The answer is that I will attend to the posted speed limit, and if they want to be in MY COUNTRY, they can get in line behind those that have waited AND PAID THOUSANDS to enter MY COUNTRY legally.

        1. I think government is messed up inviting illegals to the US for free health care when country is in so much debt is stupid. If I managed my home like political party does, I wouldn’t have a home. Stop the squandering!

      1. You’re comparing getting into America to avoid getting raped,murdered,ending up in gangs,horrible job paying rates to going 5 miles over the speed limit…. invalid

        1. If things are that bad in the countries they came from, we should be there fixing the problems, not allowing those problems to continue unabated!

          1. Oh yeah…so you would keep try to figure out how to stop gangs from killing hundreds of people and forcing others to do work for them instead of fleeing to preserve your life? You’re just mad that there are people who are fighting for protection in a country you took for grated being in. 🤷🏼‍♀️


        1. Bonnie, “this President” has broken so many laws, we still don’t know all of them. He acts as if he is above all laws so he is hardly the person to hold up as an example for someone who can decide what is or is not a law. Most ‘laws’ in our Country are currently biased in favor of wealthy white people.
          DACA was created to allow people, who have lived here their entire life, since childhood to find a path to citizenship, except Congress was unable to pass any pathway to citizenship. or make DACA permanent. These kids were minors when decisions were made for them. Anyone with compassion, does not blame kids for their parents actions.
          These kids were brought up by hardworking parents (the kids are also), trying to provide a better life for their kids; most parents can relate to that and realize if they were in the same situation; they would also move heaven and earth to try to make their kids lives better..
          A higher percentage of Undocumented workers pay their fair share of taxes than the general population and yet are unable to get qualify for social security, insurance or government subsidies, which they would qualify for because they are not making a living wage. Their tax dollars went to support the rest of the population.
          They worked jobs that currently, small farmers and businesses can’t fill and years ago, they did not just march into this country; they were invited even recruited for farm work.
          As a result of tariffs and no workers for smaller farms, farms (and small businesses) that relied on their labor, are going bankrupt at an alarming rate. Why do you think the Koch Bros., who want no government benefits for any Americans, want to keep DACA and Immigrants. They want them for all the wrong reasons.
          What you should be thinking is: how do we reverse the Income Inequality that is so out of whack, we have the highest poverty rate than all the Industrialized nations. Profit is going to the top 1% and not shared with workers like before the 70s, when the Neoliberalism Ideology became the economic policy of politicians (both Parties), When unions were busted, rights for workers slashed, corporations could move factories out of the country and not pay taxes. All the while, safety nets for the middle class and poor were slashed and continue to be. People were indoctrinated into the Trickle down theory (Big Lie but it worked for decades; people passively allowed the corporate takeover that has created the current Oligarchy.
          People who think undocumented workers took away well paying jobs with benefits from citizens are deluding themselves.
          Your President continues to follow the path of neoliberals and conservatives (both Democrats and Republicans), who work for their Corporate Donors/Billionaires and not for working people and THAT is why more and more people are losing ground as jobs and factories go overseas. wages stay stagnant while goods, housing, education etc continue to rise out of reach of most and the Healthcare Industry and BIG PHARMA are literally killing people and bankrupting over a million families Annually.
          This country can and needs to replenish it’s work force as it has for over 100 years in order to generate a robust economy that will support a retired work force that has lost it’s savings (due a lot to the loss of homes in 2008, pilfered pension funds and education costs soaring) or would you have old folks tossed aside also?

        2. I don’t think you really know what the meaning of being a dreamer is most of them where brought here as a child how is it their fault most of them don’t even know the country they where born in they only know AMERICA so sending them back wouldn’t even make sense I do feel sorry for those that had no fault of how they came in this country cause now they’re the one getting the back lash for something their parents did

        3. Im 16, and Im also adopted in a white American family. In school we learn that the world is progressing, learning to be more accepting and tolerant. As a Mexican, my family has shielded me from this type of negativity, that I for one was foolish to think it wasn’t around anymore. But to think there’s people as selfish as you who compare getting a better life for your family and breaking a speed limit law Is disrespectful to all the people who have fought to give there families a better life(which I bet you would have done the same if you were in that position). Just because you were born here, have a social security number, and papers form this country that doesn’t mean your better then us who weren’t as lucky. Cause that’s all it is LUCK, you could have been the one fighting in a Country that doesn’t want you there and doesn’t believe your worthy of it. But since you weren’t on the other side you think all this is just an “INVASION“ (maybe you should go through some history books and figure out how America became America). People like you are only slowing down progression in the USA. I truly hope that my generation isn’t as selfish and as vain as yours, and that we can find a way to Better our society’s as a whole, not just for those who believe to be entitled to more just for being “a true American” cause honestly I don’t believe you even understand what an American is.

      3. Joyce Varisco, you speak for me. These people that are standing for illegal aliens cannot see beyond the end of their noses.

        1. Well you certainly are deplorable. Your name suits you. Are you some entitled brat that wholly supports white supremacy? If you really think about it, the Dreamers are as American as you are. They have a right to live here too, as much as you do. How would you feel, if you grew up in one place for essentially all your life, and then you were suddenly kicked out into a strange place, with a strange language, and strange people? The only people who can’t see beyond the end of their noses is you and those that think like you. Honestly, EVERY SINGLE DREAMER is probably a better person than you are. Your kind of mentality is what’s making this country worse. Not them.

      4. I’d like to see the US build on our tradition of grace and empathy. I believe the long term solution lies in better policies that support legal immigration. Many in the caravan from Honduras were seeking asylum from violence, which is a recognized reason to process their applications, but others that joined the group were fleeing poverty and simply seeking opportunity. Why don’t we support the Dreamers that were brought here illegally by their parents? My bleeding liberal heart just cannot imagine uprooting them from their homes, schools, jobs and friends. Registration with assurances and no harassment or fees should be worked out. Eric

  4. It’s still makes me sad to hear what people think about dreamers. Sometimes you just got to put yourself in those shoes. I’m a daca recipient and those who just meet me have no idea base on my appearance. I’m sure you’ve met many dreamers and never realized they were “Illegal ”
    I consider USA to be my home and always will, even though I’m categorized as an “illegal “. Thanks to daca, I get to do what I love and love what I do, and that’s to serve my community. I work as a firefighter and have had the opportunity to help the beautiful citizens of California. Every morning I work, I proudly raise OUR flag and pay my respects.
    I love helping others regardless of their background. I just wish people saw things with an open heart and mind and simply be a kind, loving humans. Yes, I’m all for locking up those who commit crimes and those who hurt others but the majority of the dreamers are just trying to have a life in a country we consider our home.

    1. Humans are not “illegal”.
      I know there are many people who do not seem to have the capacity for empathy and it is really hard for those of us who do and grieve for the pain and suffering that they are inflicting on others.
      There are no words for people, who tear children/babies from their parents arms, put them in cages, drug some, and subject them to horrible treatment and then purposely, lose many of them under the premise as it would deter other refugees from coming to America, many of whom are fleeing the result of our country’s regime change actions in their countries, the past.
      This is a very dark time in our country, condemned by everyone with a beating heart. The people, who actually claim, it’s the parents fault for bringing their children here (fleeing starvations and homicide in a lot of cases) are soulless.
      I know there are more people, who care than ones, who hate.

    2. Anonymous – You sound like a person I would love to have as my friend and my neighbor.
      What steps are you taking to become naturalized?
      (Full disclosure. I am fully against any blanket amnesty for illegals. I would support amnesty on a case by case basis. I realize there are many like you that love our Country and would vote in her best interest if given a chance. )

  5. My daughter’s boyfriend is a good kid whose parents were not able to obtain DACA for him so now he’s 17 almost 18 and was brought here at 3 years old and is stuck without the ability to get a regular job or a driver’s license and really wants to be able to afford college! This new bill would benefit a good kid!

  6. How can they start a process when illegals aren’t allowed to work without a social or work permit and in order to obtain either you would have to have a job to make money to pay for the process

    1. Through DACA I was able to receive my necessary permit & ss# for work/study purposes. That’s how you get a job, make money, save up & pay the fees necessary.

  7. I am completely against amnesty and just giving people citizenship. I am in favor of giving Dreamers (and only Dreamers) a pathway to done kind of a resident status that must be requified every 5 years. That status should be granted only long as they have never broken any jaws at all and they were legally protected as a Dreamer before 1/1/2016. No one after 1/1/2016 should ever be able to qualify as a Dreamer / DACA again. I am completely against giving the students federal student loans or in-state tuition. Any of them who left the country or were deported should not be allowed to re-enter under the program. They must apply to come in with no special considerations through the usual immigration system. I am completely against giving any kind of legal status to anyone other than Dreamers who are in our country illegally. I am completely against any manner of hindering the deportation of any person in our country illegally and in particular, anyone with any kind of criminal history.

    1. Pam Berry – You speak for me also. Word for word!
      Give the Dreamers amnesty. Stop the Anchor baby process and stop chain migration!
      Someone write a stand alone bill that contains these words and I am all in!

    2. I totally understand you’re idea of amnesty, but I have a question. What’s wrong with the Dreamers getting student loans or in-state tuition? If anything, they should be the ones getting the help, after all, as they are the ones with fewer resources to achieve the same hopes and dreams that regular citizens, with more access to help, want to achieve. I may not be a dreamer, so my situation is different, but I am still an immigrant, and it’s so difficult to do the same things many of my friends are doing because I wasn’t lucky enough to be born in the US. But I’m also in a unique situation where I could get deported, and after living here since I was two, it’s going to be near impossible to adjust to a completely different setting. Dreamers are human too. They still have dreams. While they may have entered the US illegally, they had no choice in the matter, and they grew up as American. While they shouldn’t be granted immediate amnesty, they should still be given the opportunity to be citizens too, not be deported to a strange place that they aren’t a part of. In this case, it isn’t the best of both worlds. The dreamers are receiving the WORST of both worlds.

  8. Do something for those legal folks in Nebraska and Iowa instead please! There are tens of thousands of affected Americans due to a broken climate who need your help RIGHT now! You should start thinking about those folks first.

    1. You are in wrong post my friend. This is talking about immigration issues. Not climate or natural disaster help. There is no monetary benefit to offering immigrants a chance to be legal. They still have to make their own money just like any american working everyday. Now if you were talking about, for example. Building a wall which requires money, or helping states, with natural disasters. Like Nebraska and Iowa or Flint. Then that would be a valid protest.

  9. My husband came here when he was only 2 years old…he went to school, collage and now teaching in High School like a Math teacher…never had a chance to travel outside the Usa cause his status, never had a chance to see his country…always hoping for some law which will give him a chance to be completely part of this country, cause he thinks in English not in another language…if he is loosing this opportunity, very great promise for him, he has to move outside this country, somewhere where never been, somewhere where nobody knows him, somewhere where is gonna be crazy hard to begin a new life style…is not impossible but I’m just asking to think about like a human been and put all of you in his situation or other like him. My husband came here legally but his parents decide to stay and never had a chance to get citizenship cause no law exist from the 1992(the year he came) to give him a chance to get this done…what he can do now?

    1. Illegal folks are illegal, period. Why there is a push for forgiveness for those that violate the law, yet, it would be a disgrace for those who subjected themself to or has honored the law of this country. Illegals are illegals. The border must be protected, and I surely do not want people in this country who violate the law, in their first attempt to settle here. America does not need these people.

      1. Honestly, ignorant. Theres so many americans who violate the law too. Ignorant racist is what you are! Dont speak like everyone is like that. Just like you have the opportunity, everyone deserves one too.

        1. Name calling and rants do not negate the fact that the Law was broken. Yes, there are Americans that violate laws and they are punished. What makes anybody else who came illegally so special. Are you saying all people who entered illegally are exempt from America’s laws? Americans have certain opportunities but you can’t break in and demand those opportunities just because you were successful at breaking the law. Opportunities are earned and America is not responsible for the world. It seems to me that the Anger that is harbored belongs to the country they left for not providing opportunities. Their protest should have begun there.

          1. You say that people entered illegally. Plenty of Dreamers entered the country legally but have overstayed a visa, due to complications in the US immigration policy. I can see how you feel targeted as a narrowminded and incompetent individual, but no worries. While dreamers are fighting for our country, we still need people like you to complain and whine about their own misfortunes. Thank you for your service.

        2. maybe but if we have laws then enforce them
          thousands have no right to just march in to this country and stay

        1. “Those people” “These immigrants” so much disrespect. It’s obvious that people like you think they are better then us. I mean I came to this country at the age of one my parents worked so hard for me to get a better education. I’m a surgeon who saves people’s life’s, Ive contributed millions of dollars to health organizations. And yet, i don’t qualify as an American cause I wasn’t born here😂. I just have a question, what have you done that makes a better then us?

      2. U do realize some like me were brought at the age of one, the U.S is my home. I know nothing but the U.S way of living. My English outweighs my Spanish greatly. I am no less a U.S Citizen than those that were actually born here. The only difference is the year I was in my birth country. All I want is to work and feel safe like everyone around me.

        1. Dear Just Another American – What efforts are you making to become a legal American resident? What efforts?

      3. Moses leading his people to the promised land was an illegal act, too. in fact, history is full of such examples-Martin Luther King, Nelson Mandela. Ask people what was legal and illegal in Nazi Germany. Don’t give me that “illegal is illegal.” Instead ask what is moral and right, and try to change the law to reflect that.

      4. It’s still makes me sad to hear what people think about dreamers. Sometimes you just got to put yourself in those shoes. I’m a daca recipient and those who just meet me have no idea base on my appearance. I’m sure you’ve met many dreamers and never realized they were “Illegal ”
        I consider USA to be my home and always will, even though I’m categorized as an “illegal “. Thanks to daca, I get to do what I love and love what I do, and that’s to serve my community. I work as a firefighter and have had the opportunity to help the beautiful citizens of California. Every morning I work, I proudly raise OUR flag and pay my respects.
        I love helping others regardless of their background. I just wish people saw things with an open heart and mind and simply be a kind, loving humans. Yes, I’m all for locking up those who commit crimes and those who hurt others but the majority of the dreamers are just trying to have a life in a country we consider our home.

        1. I came in this country when I was 20, I applied to a program called Harifa. Because of lawyer negligence an being careless I was denied. The Haiti earthquake had happening I was enrolled on Tps. I am not a criminal. I been suffering bc of this legal status, I paid my taxes for the past 15 years. I paid also my tuition fees. I was able to earn a master in Math no debt I am working in the nursing field for the past 15 years. taking care of patients. I deserve a little relief. Haiti is insecure now


            1. Bonnie, I get it, you are heartless and feel you can justify it. I bet if you were the victim of an earthquake you would expect to get help. Why? because you pay taxes? Working undocumented workers (people cannot be Illegal!) pay their taxes also. or would you expect it for yourself because you happened to be born here? Wow, seems like that was your parents “choice”, not you and you can’t seem to wake up one day and realize you just happened to be lucky! You didn’t earn being a citizen. Many undocumented workers earned being citizen but because of our lousy immigration laws, can’t get a path to citizenship. They were promised citizenship in past years but they were left hanging. Wake up.

      5. One thing you forget that this was Mexico difference is your ancestors came into our country killing people in masses and you think people coming here illegal is wrong study your history before you speak

  10. I am a dreamer and always wonder why NEA has never gotten legislation passed to forgive all students government loans for all Americans who have paid taxes for a few years after graduation from college. I am against student loan money wasted on those who never use the education and often default on debts. But our most promising graduates who have proven themselves should be set free of this bondage. This may be the best thing for voters and investment in our economy Congress could do this session.

  11. As a long retired teacher and current volunteer in Coachella Valley, it is time to help students have full access to legal status. After 3 to 5 years, these students are American in speech, thought, and goals for their lives.

  12. good morning,

    My name is Michelle A I am 21 years old, I am a DREAMER and also a PARENT to a amazing 10 month old baby boy. I am writing today to show and proof my support for this new possible law. I am constantly worried about my life and future with my child, i am constantly afraid of possibly being separate from my son and my family. I’ve been in this country for more than 10 years i dont know anything else but this country i take pride in being apart of this country. WE had no choice when they we were brought here. This has been OUR country for many years. It’s time that WE get recognize as fellow citizens and use our youth, energy and enthusiasm to rebuild the American Dream!

    1. Why not return to your home country which needs you? Also be proud of your country, whose people I am pretty sure fought hard so you could live and grace the people there? Think of this.

      1. You moron will never know why our parents or children move to USA, because you have never been in a place where there is no food, no job, no safety on the streets like here in USA. We came here because we had to fight and survive however possible. And please don’t even think to say we are taking your jobs or your food stamp, because thats just pathetic of you. We work hard every day just like you, we pay bills just like you and we pay taxes just like you we our ITIN numer.

          1. Dear people of the United States of America,
            My name is Goose and I was born in a land beyond the borders of the USA. I remember very little of my home country and even less of the people who I left behind like the feel of a warm hug from them. Video and phone calls is all I’ve had since I left my country. I can’t say I enjoy this very much because it is a reminder that I may not get a chance to see them any time in the near future. What’s more is I grew up in a town where I felt out of place but have since accepted my new home. It’s a bit funny to have been born in one place but only being able to call a new land a home. This country seemed to be a scary place when I arrived because I knew of only 3 people like me in my area. Though as a child you really can’t tell much of a difference between yourself and a classmate. This country has had many voices that spoke volumes to me like all men being created equal and people reguardless of color being able to live peacefully and being able to pursue happiness. I enjoyed the first 15 years of my life which were in bliss because I was so ignorant about how different my life was to the person next to me. My parents didn’t let me be a part of any school sports team because they feared that I would at some point have the potential to get injured and that my status without citizenship/legal status would cause a major financial burden when it came time to pay hospital bills. Parents aren’t there to warn you about that stuff when you’re supposed to not be somewhere legally and as such I found out that I wasn’t legal when a teacher asked about an SSN so that she could try to enroll me in a gifted school when I was in 6th grade. I didn’t know what not having an SSN really meant back then but I stayed in school and lived knowing any time I needed an SSN my answer was supposed to be thank you but I can’t accept that. Not to gifted schooling and not to scholarships. I went on a few more years and in highschool I started to get interested in getting a job and then I didn’t tell my parents I was going to apply . I walked into a restaurant one day and asked for an app and soon realized that an SSN was needed and I cried because I didn’t know what else to do. I was 15 with good grades and a desire to do something with my life. A manager walked in and saw me cry. He asked what was wrong and I told him. He took that paper and said don’t worry there’s a lot more people in your situation , more than you know and this well it’s just a peice of paper. That changed my life because for the first time I actually felt like there was some hope. Obama granted people DACA and I was so relieved because I would be able to finally attend higher education and so here is where I am now. Leaving the country would ban me for 10 years and would mean I have no where to go because I don’t know anyone in my country of birth. Staying in my home means that for now I have some protection against being forced to leave and that I can see my friends and extended family. Yet it also means that I can’t visit my blood family. My blood family is dirt poor and it would be a huge inconvenience to them to have me there and would also mean that I can no longer help them through financial support. Even though I haven’t held them in my arms for what would now by 18 years I am still very much a person who cares for family blood and extended. I am heartbroken by the choice of either especially because I already call a place my home and it is a life I am so used to living. I am depicted as a criminal in this country because of my status but otherwise I have no criminal history, not even a parking ticket to my name. The US gave Dreamers a chance to leave before they became official criminals the choice wasn’t easy to make though . Here’s the choice leave at 18 and up to what 6 months in with virtually no penalty….leave before a year was up with a 3 year ban or anytime after would be a potential 10 year ban. I suppose that’s the right amount of time that parents would tell their kids ok here’s what your life was and now we’re gonna leave you in a different country where you don’t have a place to stay , you don’t have money or a job. Good luck

      2. This was not necessary. It was racist. It was ignorant. I will pray for your soul’s salvation from condemnation.

  13. If they are going to be given amnesty it needs to be dated instead of saying if you came here under the age of 18 a been in the country four years. It needs to say if you came to the u.s. under the age 18 prior to January 1st 2016

  14. Dreamers are truly Americans and should be given the chance to live in and continue to contribute to the United States, the country they know and love.

  15. Surely you will vote for the Dream and Promise act for everyone in Tennessee! You know in your heart, soul, and mind that it the right thing to do.

  16. Dreamers are good people who only want to achieve their American Dreams. Our gov’t should focus on the most pressing problems rather than hinder those who can help our country progressed more. America was built by immigrants! and they continue to do so.

  17. The country Dreamers know as home should not turn its back on them; not with so much time and treasure invested for them and by them to be able to meaningfully participate in our society. Providing them the capacity to transition to U.S. citizenship is morally and pragmatically the right thing to do.

  18. All should be welcomed if they follow the rules of becoming a citizen. Those that do not should be deported. We should not be a welfare country!

        1. Beautifully said some people speak just to speak and they dont get informed once and for all WE DONT QUALIFY OR WILL EVER QUALIGY FOR GOVERNMENT HELP. We aren’t taking anything from anyone we are just hard workers paying taxes just like everyone else so stfu already with your false info

  19. I am in my 40th year in education. Propaganda like this is why I have stopped my membership to the NEA and the WEA. I will continually stand against both organizations which continually enter into leftist agendas which are not what the unions should be dealing with. I am embarrassed that I took so long drop out.

  20. America IS immigrants and their children. Ask Mr. Drumph’s grandfather.
    We are all immigrants or their children, and we have built America.

  21. I do not know anyone who wants people born in the US to be deported, and neither does Trump or anyone in Congress. I also do not know anyone who wants those here illegally to not be deported if they are not legally eligible to stay. So how does this bill solve this dilemma without separating families with children under eighteen years of age???

  22. These young people had no choice when they were brought here. This has been their country-many have never really known another country. It’s time that we recognize them as fellow citizens and use their youth, energy and enthusiasm to rebuild the American Dream!

    1. There was amnisty granted in the late 1980’s, but nothing was done to correct the illegal immigration problem, so the problem continues. The ONLY way to make DACA kids a path to citizenship is to FIRST correct the issue of illegal immigration, then and only then can DACA be addressed.

    2. Trump was not inhuman, he saw the problem of illegals not paying for American privileges paid for by taxes paid by law abiding citizens. If a person is progressing towards citizenship, contributing, and abiding by the laws, they are welcome. Stop making provisions for those who are not doing the previous, it sapps the systems and burdens those abiding. Keep revising to bring equality to all, not just minors of all races not willing to contribute.

    3. Here is my question. Why haven’t they tried to become a citizen before this? Why should we be the ones who start this process? I would think if it was important to them, they would have started the process long before now.

      1. You are so ignorant at this immigration problem. Do you think an immigrant can just go and grab an application for citizenship and fill it up and walaaa he/she is a citizen?!? No!!
        There is a 99% he/she will be detained and deported! You ignorant!!

      2. Please read up on this country’s immigration processes and then you tell us why people don’t just apply for residency, which then allows you to become a citizen after some time. Don’t you think people have tired to become naturalized from their country before coming here? Of course they have and people still do try and go through the process, but it takes YEARS and they can be denied even if they have no criminal history. However, people & their families can’t wait years where there is war, violence, corruption, & famine. It’s easy to say, just fix what’s going on at home, but that means risking death. Immigrants also risk death to get here soooo it is up to all of us to stand up for what is morally right for those who are deserving and have paid their dues. Because contrary to popular belief, these immigrants do pay taxes! By granting these millions of qualified law-abiding people a more permanent legal status, will allow more people to work and keep paying taxes which is all great for the economy! And isn’t that one of the goals this administration is striving for? Hope this helps!

    4. Yes, do the humane thing for our them to assimilate. Relieve their fear. I can’t imagine living with such uncertainty. Where is the empathy?

  23. President Trump’s treatment of immigrant families is not cruel and inhumane. He has made amazing efforts to help DACA students, but Democrats insist on their way or the highway. Lily Garcia conspicuously omits the word “illegal” from her reference to immigrants. There is a huge difference between “illegal” and “legal” immigrants, but Garcia’s misleading statement implies that Trump is inhumane and cruel to all immigrants. That is an outright lie. He is not cruel to any immigrants. However, many illegal immigrants, protected in sanctuary cities, have murdered and raped our citizens. Let’s be sure to tell the truth, Lily.

    Now, in the interest of “diversity” of opinion, championed by NEA, post my statement for all to see, preferably in our esteemed publication, NEA Today.

      1. I agree, As a tps holder. The democrats are a little bit demagogue. Trump had addressed the issues. They should resolve the problem before Trump step in. In my opinion Trump is not that mean . I know a lot of friends as his body guard .

  24. A very, very, very rich spoiled brat: “Prince” Trump was never, NEVER EVER of the common People & then for the majority common People in the United States. NO!

  25. There are many US citizens whose parents did not bring them here illegally that would love to realize such a dream . In fact I would of appreciated someone paying for my children’s education . This is just not fair . We can not help everyone . I wish we could but what about myself and my family . I do not support this bill .

    1. “In fact I would of appreciated someone paying for my children’s education”. Same here. This is not fair to those who came here legally, those who were born here – those who fight for this country.

      1. No one is asking for anyone to pay for these young people’s education. Where did you get that? DACA recipients are eligible to work & therefore must pay taxes… duh. Why should they not be allowed to apply for FAFSA and get a college education to further themselves and be an asset to this country when they have lived here and paid their taxes? Ignorance is not bliss.

    2. Wellllll, if your kid works hard enough in school, they have access to scholarships and grants, which DACA recipients do not have access to. I’m sure you would appreciate someone taking your responsibility as a parent and paying for their education, but because they worked hard and earned it and are deserving or because you feel they are “entitled” to it? DACA recipients and illegal immigrants pay and file taxes, put money into the system, but aren’t allowed the benefits. Having access to financial aid, they aren’t taking from your kid, they are accessing something they should have access to because they bring money in.

  26. Where are the humane acts for generations of Americans born here, who fought for religious, economic, educational freedom; died for equity, equality, unbiased justice; whose children are in hundreds of thousands of dollars debt to get educated?

  27. Most of the foreigners here I know would be deported if they applied for welfare. Most of our ancestors were like them years ago running from a country and situation that had no good life for them, and if they made it here they’d have an opportunity to get a life. Many have started their own businesses to become American too, and are good citizens. Then they should be welcome to make a life here as we were able by our ancestors. But the Robinhood government programs do need to stop as well as the support of what is not working out for our people. Work for what is given needs to be put in place instead of return. There is a time that changes needs to be made, and the government should not bail out what is bad for us to support. I have supported many who came to this country looking for a better life. How big the government has gotten, and it’s power base to be able to take from us has grown to what we ran from in other countries. The insurance program at one time was a great answer but now with deductibles that can never be paid, this needs to stop…. these are our robbers… you don’t show for an appointment and they charge you and your insurance Co. anyway… that’s a robber. These people who come here are taking jobs we won’t take, doing what we won’t do. Proper application of them into our mix, of those are here, needs to be accommodated.

  28. As a member in the community in the city of Coachella where many of our residents have an ancestral history of origin from Mexico, and as an educator, athletic coach, and former Mayor who has experienced fellow residents who have integrated and have patriotically served in so many arenas of society, I fully support these efforts to fully include them into our American family.

  29. My parents were immigrants. They became valuable citizens and contributed to this country with three children: one PhD, two Masters. Don’t deny others the opportunity.

  30. We are a nation of immigrants. It is time we give the Dreamers their Constitutional right to citizenship.

  31. Support the Dream and Promise Act of 2019 (H.R. 6) that provides young immigrants and TPS holders a path to citizenship.

  32. It’s time to take steps forward with the nation right now, today for them tomorrow for us.

    This will be a historic progress for the entire nation, a sign of intelligence, a humane action that is well deserved.

    1. I am the son of an immigrant. My father entered this country 70 years ago, fought in WWII, held a job until his death and never committed a felony crime.

      H.R. 6 would give all aliens (illegal immigrants) exemption from any possible deportation by the US, even if they committed a felony.

      Congress certainly needs to correct the current immigration policies. They need to do so without making this a political issue. All sides agree that the policy needs to be updated. The current administration did not “recklessly” terminate DACA. It was temporary by definition. The previous administration failed to follow through with needed immigration reform policy. The current administration followed the rule of law and allowed DACA to end according to the previous administration’s pre-determined date.

      H.R.6 does NOT justly correct this policy. For example, H.R. 6 prohibits the US justice system from deporting any alien (illegal immigrant) on the basis on ANY crime (including felonies) if that alien has come from a country or culture of violence. Since this is also the basis for many aliens wishing to enter the US, it would effectively give illegal immigrants the right to do anything they wished in the US without fear of prosecution.

      Please read H.R. 6 to note this and other flaws and inadequacies in the bill.

    2. We are a Nation built on the principles of expanding opportunities for All. That begins with education, continues, and ends with education. “Empty the coins in your purse into your mind, and your mind will fill your purse with coins.” Benjamin Franklin

      1. Give me your coins and I will surely do that, Bill, err, Ben. I will redistribute to those in need, too.

    3. For the immigrants that came here illegally they knew their children would be American citizens. The parents should have tried for citizenship at that time. For the ones that didn’t or haven’t even tried should be sent back. If they don’t won’t to be separated from their children let them leave with their parents. They shouldn’t cry about it, they took chances when they came here. We don’t want to separate families they make that choice by coming here illegally. Send them all back together.

      1. Why do people keep saying that a pathway to citizenship for immigrants brought here as children to be AMNESTY?

        Amnesty only applies to people that have commited a crime.
        When a child commits murder it is arguably NOT a crime and therefore Amnesty is not applicable.

        These kids that were brought here had no say in the matter.
        They have no other home but America. They are NOT criminals and therefore the word AMNESTY does not apply.

        Pass the Dream Act Now!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *