My opinion: PA budget or Hell freezing over…which will come first?


Guest blogger: Peter Greene

I’ve been waiting to write a reaction to a new Pennsylvania budget just as soon as it’s passed, but I would clearly be further ahead to check weather reports from Hell for news of a deep freeze.

Take Action ›

Get the latest pro-student and pro-teacher education and political news with the free weekly Education Votes email. Click here ›

As 2016 gets under way, the PA budget crisis is approaching the 200-day mark, over half a year now gone with the legislature unable to do their job, and if anything, the prospects are now worse.

The story so far is pretty simple. Governor Tom Wolf and GOP legislators negotiated a compromise budget. The GOP-controlled Senate voted for it. Then some wacky members in the House, which is also controlled by Republicans, scuttled the whole thing.

In December the House bet that everyone was so desperate that the budget that was no good in June would now be acceptable. So they submitted a budget that included a $95 million cut for education, which, if approved, would surely harm students, and no money at all for state universities like Pitt and Penn State.

PA educator and blogger Peter Greene

The governor “accepted” it, allowing money to be turned loose for the school districts and human service providers that haven’t been paid by the state yet this year, but he line-item vetoed all but $23 billion of that budget– including about half the basic education appropriation– angrily calling the budget “garbage.”

None of this reassured Standard and Poor’s, who had dropped PA’s debt rating in September. S&P indicated that they saw no need to upgrade the still-budgetless state.

And that pile of emergency money for public schools and kids? The GOP is upset at how the governor is choosing to disperse it. The funds will save some districts from the worst financial straits, but it won’t answer the question, “How much money are we getting from the state for our budget?” That question applies both to the budget for the year that’s half over and the budget for next year, which most districts are currently trying to write because even though they have no way of knowing what the state payments will be, you have to meet your budget deadlines. Right?

The Big December fail also scuttled the latest version of pension reform (a teacher-spanking reform that some lawmakers say must have been good because ALEC liked it).

Pulling Pennsylvania schools and its students back from the brink of disaster may even harm long-term chances for a solution, as legislators may feel less urgency. It probably doesn’t help that we have entered an election year; the looming elections guarantee that politicians will be concerned about posturing, and Pennsylvania’s highly-gerrymandered map insures that political posturing means playing to the base. Social media already have a fair share of commenters who applaud the GOP obstructionism because it keeps the state from raising taxes.

Pennsylvania has one of the largest, most expensive legislatures in the country, but they have one main job that they cannot get done. This stalemate already ranks as Pennsylvania’s longest budget impasse ever (and we’ve had plenty). Can we achieve the impressive feat of going an entire year without a budget? I’m not ready to place my bets yet, but I will certainly keep checking those weather reports from Hell.

Peter Greene is a 36-year veteran classroom teacher, former local union leader, and regular blogger at Curmudgucation. He is also a Progressive Education Fellow, an avid reader, and a trombonist in a 159-year-old town band. He lives in Northwest Pennsylvania with his wife and their chocolate lab. You can follow Peter’s blog on Facebook and Twitter.

Reader Comments

  1. The author mentions, “playing to the base…” What a strategy!
    The GOP strategy of relying on the tried and true (or should I say, tired and false) rhetorical claim that they are the ones who feel the pain of the hard-working tax payers, and that they are the party that will keep those “tax and spend” Democrats from wasting their constituents’ hard earned tax money is a conundrum of mixing the truth with lies.
    Truth= The working class IS working harder, longer hours, for less wages.
    Lies= The GOP cares nothing for their average working class constituents.

    This is evidenced by 35 years of “trickle down,” supply side economics, that has been very successful at decimating our middle class in order to deliver ever higher profit margins to the business and finance sectors. Just look at their connected-at-the-hip relationships with the well heeled donors from the local Chambers of Commerce, all the way up to “multi-national” corporations, while selling the middle class out.
    How do they pull this off? By promising the middle class the false narrative of how they are holding the line on taxes! Even as they rejected Governor Wolf’s plan to deliver as much as a 50% property tax relief for homeowners by increasing the tax on slot machines, the State’s sales tax from 6% to 6.6%, the personal income tax from 3.07% to 3.7%, and a 5% tax on PA shale with the aim to boost PA’s education budget without property owners taking a major hit. Bills have to be paid in this age of crumbling infrastructure, but he GOP would much rather see all the capital go into the deep pockets of their buddies in the business and finance sectors, while homeowners pick up the tab and renters pick up the tab.

  2. PA public schools near HELP! SPECIAL ED departments are under funded and under staff.many of their practices are antiquated. If more parents sue, maybe administration will wake up. Take a look at the percentages of your state test scores. I am from CT and PA has a long way to go. Approach your national sports team and casino from funding.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *